Digging Out Old Shrubs? Try a Spade With Teeth
A spade hits an old shrub's roots and stops dead, and the usual advice is a mattock or a saw. There's a third way to dig a bush out by hand.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Two ways to read this piece. The quick read tells it in three pictures and a few short paragraphs. The full story is the whole piece, with every source.

The spade stops at the first root
An established shrub sits on a web of roots, and a pointed blade bounces off them.
A gardener up against tough old shrubs asked a Mumsnet board what would get through. Anyone digging out an old shrub or bush by hand tends to hear the answer they got first, a mattock.

A notched tip and two rows of teeth
Another reply named the Root Slayer, a spade with a notched tip and toothed sides. It cuts through most shrub roots as you dig. A reviewer got through bigger ones by jumping on it, teeth set beside the root.
Of all one owner's digging tools, it's the one that goes in easiest.

Shrub out, saw kept for the thick ones
One bonsai collector got a bunch of old azaleas out with it, rhododendrons too, and couldn't believe how well that went.
The maker rates it for roots up to 1.25 inches thick. Past that you want a saw.
For a border full of old shrubs, the full-size original is the one to get.
Want the details?
The full story has the rest, the annoying parts included, and every source.
Stamping harder doesn't help. The point of an ordinary spade just slides off the root to one side, and the next try does the same.
Someone was clearing a very overgrown stretch of garden, all tough old shrubs, roots and rocks. They asked the gardening board on Mumsnet, a British parenting forum, for the best tools people had come across. One reply was just a name: the Root Slayer, a spade with saw teeth down both edges.
Nearly nine months later another gardener quoted that reply. They'd bought one earlier in the year and would definitely recommend it.
If you've got an old shrub, an overgrown bush or a long-established rose to dig out by hand, it's worth a look before you start swinging anything heavier. It cuts small and middling roots as it digs. The thick ones are still a saw's job.
What is a good tool for digging out bushes?
The answer most people get is a mattock. That's a heavy head on a pick handle, with a broad blade you swing down into the ground like an axe.
It was the first thing the replies in that thread named. One gardener bought theirs on the board's advice to clear a similar patch, and calls it brilliant for chopping up old roots. The next person to mention it seconded that and called it invaluable.
The Root Slayer is a spade that cuts roots on its way into the ground, so the digging and the cutting are one push of the boot.
An owner in r/landscaping says theirs slides into the ground more easily than any other digging tool they have. They call it lightweight but sturdy.
People who collect shrubs for bonsai dig established plants out whole, roots and all. In r/Bonsai, someone came back from lifting a bunch of old azaleas and rhododendrons with one. They hadn't known what to expect, and were blown away by how well it worked.
Another collector took theirs out for a season and came home with zero complaints.
What is a Root Slayer shovel?
Shovel or spade, it's the same tool. It's sold as a shovel in the US, and the British gardeners above call it a spade.
Marc Lyman of Home Fixated had a re-landscaping job with a lot of plants and shrubs to take out. Lyman ordered one for it and wrote up how it went. Going by that review, four things set it apart from the spade in your shed.
- The tip is notched. It's an upside-down V with a point on each side. A normal pointed blade skids off a root. This one traps it between its two points. Lyman found it went through smaller roots on the first try.
- Both edges are saw teeth. They did well on dense clumps of small roots.
- The top of the blade has wide steps. They give your boot a big target. Lyman jumped on both sides repeatedly and they never bent.
- The handle is a ring. You can grip it one-handed or two-handed from any angle, and pull up on it when the blade wedges in stubborn soil. The owner who called theirs lightweight finds the ring comfortable too.

How to dig up old shrub roots with it
Work your way round the plant, pushing the blade straight down. Small roots go as it does.
For a root that won't give, use the teeth on the way down. Lyman doesn't recommend gripping the spade like a handsaw and sawing. What worked on the bigger ones was this:
When I hit larger roots I would line up the edge of the shovel right next to the side of pesky root and then jump on the shovel. A few jumps and the shovel would saw right through the root.
Marc Lyman, Home Fixated
The maker's advice, as one retailer passes it on, is a calmer version of the same thing. Keep the blade upright and take lots of small bites rather than one almighty stomp, which the maker says cuts faster.
Where the teeth stop
Thick roots are still a job for a saw. Lyman says the spade handled most plant and shrub roots with relative ease. For larger tree roots, though, you might still need a reciprocating saw with a pruning blade.
The maker's own figure, on that retailer's page, is roots up to 1.25 inches thick.
The owner whose spade slides in so easily loves it, but hasn't tackled any trees over six feet with it.
Once roots get properly big, people reach for a power saw. In r/gardening, somebody was left with a cherry tree's roots that a mini excavator couldn't pull. The answer that keeps coming up there is a reciprocating saw, with a pruning blade or a long one, 12 inches.
For hand tools, one reply has used axes and a mattock as needed, and another suggests a sharp mattock alongside the saw.
Back in the thread where the spade came up, one gardener drives a hand axe into the ground to split roots into manageable pieces before digging them out.
It isn't a pry bar either. Lyman put a lot of force through the spade and it stayed in one piece. For levering, though, the advice is to get a digging bar.
The gardener who seconded the mattock has another idea for when you've got help. Take a fork each and lever the roots up together.
Which Root Slayer to get
The name now covers a whole line of tools, with a compact spade and a trowel among them. Lyman mentions a larger version with a more traditional handle too.
The original full-size spade with the ring handle is the one Lyman tested, and the one to buy. Expect to pay noticeably more than you would for a plain spade.

Start with the toothed spade and keep a saw within reach. The original Root Slayer takes you round the shrub, cutting as it goes.
A root that survives a few stamps on the step is one for the saw. When the plant finally rocks, lever it out with a fork and leave the spade out of it.

