Digby the moleDigby FindsGems dug up by a mole with good taste.

Is a Leather Tool Belt Better Than Nylon?

Leather or nylon tool belt? Tradespeople who've worn each for a decade or more lay out what really differs: weight, rain and the backs of your hands.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Two ways to read this piece. The quick read tells it in three pictures and a few short paragraphs. The full story is the whole piece, with every source.

Digby the mole stands in a hardware shop holding a tan leather tool rig in one paw and a black fabric one in the other, unsure which to pick.

Nine years of replies and still no winner

Anyone picking their first full rig is choosing between two camps. Each side can point at a belt it's worn for a decade or more. Leather owners talk about years. Nylon owners talk about weight.

A full-time electrician asked The Garage Journal for thoughts on Occidental tool belts in 2015, and replies were still arriving in 2024. Those, plus the comments under three ToolGuyd pieces, are where the answer comes from.

Wearing one pouch of each kind, Digby the mole squeezes down a narrow shop aisle, reaching into the black one while the tan one bumps the shelf.

Better for your hands, heavier on your hips

That electrician was asking about the Occidental Leather 5590 electrician's set. A carpenter who works in the rain nine months a year warned about its two nylon pockets. Reach in for wire nuts all day and your hand ends up rubbed raw.

Leather guards the backs of your hands. Weight is where it loses. A union carpenter's nylon Diamondback is at least fifteen years old and a good bit lighter. A leather owner twelve years in calls the gap huge.

Digby the mole walks off smiling toward the sunny shop door with a paper bag, leaving an empty hook on the rack of work belts.

Rain picks nylon, and the fit picks the rest

Out in the rain most of the year, nylon wins. One tradesperson's leather bags went mouldy over a weekend in the truck. Wet leather stains your clothes brown for ten years or more.

If the belt stays dry, the latest reply says you can't go wrong with either. For a weekend-only belt, any brand will do.

Then try several on, since every rig fits differently. Start with the leather set the thread was about, with a nylon one beside it.

Want the details?

The full story has the rest, the annoying parts included, and every source.