How to Pick Up Nails in the Yard After a Roof Replacement
The roofers swept and you're still finding nails in the gravel, with kids, dogs and tyres to think of. One cheap tool finds what their sweep missed.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Two ways to read this piece. The quick read tells it in three pictures and a few short paragraphs. The full story is the whole piece, with every source.

The crew swept, but the nails are still there
Anyone who just had roofers, gutter fitters or a deck crew round is about to find what they dropped. In r/daddit, one roofing crew swept with magnets and left nails anyway. Another was still finding them after several passes.
One gutter crew left without cleaning up, and months of shards and screws followed. In r/homeowners, the person asking had a toddler and three dogs to keep off them. Somebody else held out until a screw went through their heel.

Roll a bar magnet over the gravel
Push a bar magnet across the ground on wheels and the nails, screws and staples leap up and stick to it. Whoever started the r/daddit thread felt silly pushing it past the neighbours, but it paid for itself inside minutes.
One r/HomeImprovement owner has the Neiko 24-inch rolling sweeper and says it lifts the odd nail from just below the surface. A release lever empties it in one pull, and a 24-inch owner in r/homeowners calls theirs worth buying.

Two coffee cans in the first month
Expect a haul, and expect it to keep coming. After an addition, one family's month of near-daily passes came to two coffee cans of nails, staples and screws.
One person in r/daddit still finds the odd nail seven years after moving in. The one with the screw in their heel sweeps again every six months, for what the rain brings up.
Get the rolling sweeper while the ladders are still up, and sweep as soon as the van pulls out.
Want the details?
The full story has the rest, the annoying parts included, and every source.
The roofers packed up on Friday. They swept, or said they did. On Sunday you find a roofing nail in the gravel by the back step, point up, right where the kids run out to the trampoline.
If a roof, gutters, a deck, a fence or an addition was just finished at your place, there's one tool to buy before the first flat tyre. It's a magnet on wheels. You push it like a broom, and the yard hands over what the crew left behind.
Didn't the crew already sweep?
Probably. It doesn't matter much. Across r/daddit and r/homeowners, people whose roofers swept with magnets, or supposedly swept several times, still found nails afterwards. The one with the multiple sweeps went over the lawn with an old metal detector and found a bunch more.
Gutters can be worse. One family's crew did no clean-up at all and left them picking up metal shards and screws for months.
One family found them on the driveway for years, long enough for a phrase to form in the house: construction crews "leak nails and screws".
The post that started the daddit thread makes the best case for owning one. Their contractors had done a decent job of cleaning up.
I felt a fool for buying a magnetic sweeper and running it along the outside of my house for passerbyers to see, but within the first couple minutes it paid for itself.
u/misterneem, in r/daddit
Their reasons were a small kid and a flat tyre. Nobody else in these threads strays far from that list: tyres, bare feet, kids and dogs.
One dad bought one after two flat tyres. Another only got round to it after a screw through the heel.
What is a magnetic sweeper?
A bar magnet in a housing, two wheels and a long handle. You push it across the ground, and nails, screws, staples and drill bits jump up and stick to the underside. The better ones have a release lever on the handle. Pull it and the whole load drops off, so you're not picking nails off a magnet by hand.
The Neiko 24-inch rolling sweeper is that shape, and one owner in r/HomeImprovement finds theirs grabs something just below the surface now and then.
Master Magnetics makes a 24-inch push sweeper with a release as well, and the daddit poster finds their magnets as strong as advertised. Pick by width and the lever, not the badge.
If yours has no lever, there's a trick in the daddit thread. Wrap a rag or a plastic bag over the magnet before you start, then pull the wrap off and everything comes away with it.

What comes up is the surprising part. One family that added on to their house ran a sweeper almost daily for the first month and filled two big coffee cans with nails, staples and screws.
In r/homeowners, someone's haul was two water bottles' worth, including seven-inch nails that must once have held part of the house up.
A homeowner who'd had major work done pulled rusty knife blades out of their driveway gravel along with the screws. They park on that gravel.
Just the number of screws I pulled out of the gravel where I park my car makes me confident that the sweeper more than paid for itself in tyres.
u/prolixia, in r/daddit
Does it work on grass and gravel?
Mostly, with one caveat. The daddit poster's worked on pavement, lawn, gravel and dirt. One reply disagreed: on anything but a flat surface the bottom of the magnet scrapes along the ground and the thing becomes almost unusable. Expect it to be happiest on a driveway and a mown lawn, and lift it over the rough bits.
It only reaches the surface. In r/HomeImprovement, one answer to the magnet-or-metal-detector question was that a magnet pulls up nails from a thinner depth of soil than a detector can find metal.
Someone who uses one at a landfill says it doesn't get everything out of gravel and dirt.
Two things it can't touch at all. Aluminium and stainless steel don't stick to a magnet, so aluminium nails and some deck screws stay where they are. Glass stays too. Two people in the r/homeowners thread wished for a version that worked on it, because they "keep finding shards" after every clean-up.
How long will you keep finding nails?
Longer than feels reasonable. Seven years after moving into a new build, one person in r/daddit still occasionally finds nails and screws in the gravel by the house. Another warning from the same thread is to expect them for a long while even after several passes over the yard.
Rain keeps bringing things up. The one who took the screw through the heel runs the sweeper again every six months or so for whatever the rain has exposed.
Treat it as a routine rather than a one-off. Run it every day or two for the first couple of weeks, while the ground is still giving things up. Again after the first hard rain, and then once or twice a year before barefoot season.
Before you buy one
- Ask the crew first. Contractors are expected to run a magnet after any job. One reply in r/daddit says to build it into the contract and ask for a daily sweep rather than one at the end.
- Borrow one if the yard is small. It isn't something you'll use all the time, as the one with the screw in the heel points out, and one family checked one out from their library.
- About two feet wide. In r/Tools, one 22-inch owner finds it right for a garage and driveway and the 17-inch a bit too small. Another with the same size wanted it narrower between the plants and wider on the driveway, which is the whole trade-off. Four others in that thread argue for the smaller one: the big ones are heavy, awkward to unload and take up space.
- Get the lever. The release is the part people mention. One 24-inch owner in r/homeowners sums theirs up as two wheels, a handle and a lever to release what the magnet picks up, and calls it worth the buy.

Go for the two-foot class with a release lever. The Neiko 24-inch is the brand and width one owner in these threads uses, and the Master Magnetics 24-inch carries the magnets the daddit poster vouches for. Order it before the crew's last day, so it's by the door for the first pass the evening they leave. Then keep a coffee can beside it for what comes up.

