Which Pencil Writes on the Back of Glossy Photos?
Everyone says label old photos in pencil. Then an ordinary yellow #2 skates right off the shiny back. The fix is still a pencil, just not that one.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Two ways to read this piece. The quick read tells it in three pictures and a few short paragraphs. The full story is the whole piece, with every source.

The #2 that won't write on a 1990s print
Pencil on the back, the advice goes, before the names are lost. The yellow one in the pencil cup is the wrong pencil for the job.
Most photographs since 1960 are on resin-coated paper, the National Archives explains, and that plastic coating doesn't readily take pencil or ink. Anyone with a box of prints from those decades is up against it, and a genealogist writing in 2010 watched the coating send people to pens instead.

A 6B art pencil, softer than any #2
A #2 sits at HB on the grading scale, and each step up the B grades is a softer lead.
In 2001 a university archivist told a mailing list their archive marks resin-coated backs with a 6B. Archival Methods, a seller of photo storage supplies, names a 4B or a 6B and stocks the one it means, the Cretacolor Monolith 6B. Graphite that soft lays a line down on the plastic coating, where a #2 can't.

It smudges, so write like an archivist
The National Archives recommends soft lead and warns it smudges easily. So does ink.
Light pressure, one edge, then a sleeve. The Library of Congress wants the mark near the edge. A light hand leaves less graphite to smudge, a California State Archives reply says, and a clear sleeve spares the writing most of its wear.
If the 6B is too soft, the seller also stocks the 4B, a shade firmer. Put a 6B in the basket while the box is still open.
Want the details?
The full story has the rest, the annoying parts included, and every source.
The shoebox tends to come with one instruction: write who's in each photo on the back, in pencil, while somebody's still around who can name them. Archivists give the same advice, down to the pencil.
What they don't mean is the one in the kitchen drawer. Anyone with a shoebox of snapshots from the 1960s onwards needs a far softer grade, the kind sold as an art pencil. People who label photographs for a living have been saying so since at least 2001.
Why a #2 does nothing on a glossy back
The back of that snapshot is plastic, or near enough. The National Archives' guidance for family collections, in a page captured in 2009, says modern snapshots and most photographs since 1960 are printed on resin-coated paper, coated with plastic, and that it doesn't readily take pencil or ink. The older kind, printed on paper that feels like paper, takes an ordinary pencil fine.
Archival Methods, which sells supplies to people who store photos, agrees in its own advice: many modern photos are on a paper a normal pencil can't write on. Its newer tips page describes the back as feeling almost waxy to the touch.
A genealogist writing on Turning of Generations in 2010 hit the same wall and watched the coating push people toward pens. Pens are where the advice splits. That 2009 National Archives page says felt-tip film-marking pens write on these backs and ballpoints don't, while the seller says the archival pen it names won't write on them at all.
Which grade?
A 4B or a 6B. Pencils are graded on a scale where an everyday #2 is an HB, right in the middle.
The B grades run softer and darker from there, and the bigger the number in front of the B, the softer the lead. A 6B is several steps past a #2, which is why you buy it in an art shop.
Archival Methods updated its labeling tips in 2025 to say so: a plain #2, or one a grade or two softer, for a paper-backed print, and a 4B or 6B for a plastic-coated one. It sells the pencil it means, the Cretacolor Monolith 6B, so read it as a seller's advice. The 6B is also the grade a working archivist named long before that page existed:
An even softer pencil works better yet. We use a 6B lead pencil for marking the backs of resin-coated photographs.
Kevin Enns-Rempel, Archivist at Fresno Pacific University, on the Archives & Archivists list, 2001
That was a reply on a mailing list for archivists. He added that you might need an art supply store to find lead that soft. Twenty-five years on, that's a search box.
The colleague he was answering, at the California State Archives, had found a very soft pencil works alright on resin-coated backs and any #2 on paper prints.

Why the brand is part of the answer
A 6B from one maker isn't a 6B from another. The seller says its grades refer to the Cretacolor pencils it stocks and that other makers' scales vary. The California State Archives colleague made the same point from the other end in 2001: some #2s smudge and some don't, because graphite mixes aren't all equal.
The Cretacolor is the pencil here because it's the one the seller's grades were written against. Another maker's 6B may well write on a glossy back too. The archivist's did in 2001, though his message never says whose it was.
It's a woodless pencil, a solid rod of graphite with no wood around it. The seller warns that woodless pencils are fragile, so it's a pencil for the table rather than the bottom of a bag.
The 4B is the same pencil a little harder, and the seller recommends both. If the 6B turns out smudgier than you'd like, that's the next one to try.
Does it smudge?
Yes. The same National Archives page says so in the sentence that tells you soft lead will write:
Usually a soft lead pencil will write on these photos, but it smudges easily (as does ink).
The National Archives, guidance for family collections, captured 2009
The seller agrees that soft graphite smears when it's rubbed and erases less cleanly than a #2. Its advice stops short of 8B and 9B, which smear more again. The softness that lets it write on plastic is the softness that smears.
The 2001 thread had the same worry. Two archivists asked straight back whether leads that soft smudged or left graphite residue, one of them speaking from years of selling drafting supplies.
The California State Archives colleague, who'd tried soft pencils on resin-coated backs, found less smudging, not more. Light pressure, he added, puts less graphite down, and less graphite is less to smudge.
What you do about it comes from the same pages, in three parts:
- Along one edge, on the back. The Library of Congress's photo care guide, which covers family albums as well as its own collections, would rather you wrote on the sleeve or envelope and left the photo unmarked. If you want the name to stay with the picture, it's the back, near the edge, in soft graphite.
- A firm surface and a light touch. The National Archives' advice is a hard surface under the print and light pressure on the pencil, and the seller's is the same.
- Then a sleeve. The California State Archives reply ends on the reminder that a clear sleeve takes most of the wear off both the picture and the writing.

Order the 6B, turn the first glossy print face down on the kitchen table, and write along the bottom edge with a light hand. Start with the photo where you're the only one left who knows everyone in it.

